Hindu Editorial Analysis : 24-August-2024

The issue of sexual violence against women is a serious concern that needs urgent attention. This essay explores why our legal framework often falls short in tackling this widespread problem.

Understanding Sexual Violence

Sexual violence is defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) as any sexual act, attempt to obtain a sexual act, or other acts directed against a person’s sexuality using coercion. This includes:

  • Rape: This is defined as forced or coerced penetration, which can involve a penis, other body parts, or objects.

Historical Context and Legal Framework in India

India’s laws related to sexual violence have developed over time, influenced by various movements, including feminist and anti-caste movements. These laws cover a range of offenses, from rape to verbal abuse, and understanding this history is essential for meaningful reforms.

Importance of Minority Laws

Laws regarding sexual violence are historically significant. They help us understand the context needed for reforms and effective justice.

Intersectionality and Gender Violence

To fully grasp sexual violence legislation, we must consider intersectionality. Factors like:

  • Class
  • Caste
  • Religion
  • Geography

These influence how gender violence cases are perceived and how justice is delivered. They also shape the perception of both victims and perpetrators.

Beyond Rape Alone

Laws against rape are not enough on their own. To address the broader issue of men’s violence against women, we must also consider:

  • Dowry Deaths: Approximately 6,516 dowry deaths occur annually in India, with a low conviction rate.
  • Domestic Violence: Often underrated, this crime is prevalent across all social classes, with maximum punishments insufficient to deter offenders.
  • Stalking and Harassment: Weak legal responses allow offenders to escape consequences, perpetuating cycles of violence.
  • Marital Rape: Not recognized under current laws, marital rape remains a significant issue.

Recent Developments: Calcutta High Court Verdict

In 2023, the Calcutta High Court made a controversial ruling, advising adolescent girls to control their sexual urges. This sparked widespread debate. The court suggested:

  • Duty to Protect Dignity: It implied that girls should protect their integrity and self-worth.
  • Control of Sexual Urges: The judgment labeled sexually active girls as “losers,” which is harmful.

Fortunately, the Supreme Court later intervened, emphasizing the need to protect children from sexual offences.

Related Concerns

Despite existing laws, implementing rape laws in India is still problematic. Survivors, especially from marginalized communities, face many obstacles:

  • Corruption: Law enforcement agencies often fail to uphold justice.
  • Low Conviction Rates: Even with increased penalties, the conviction rates for sexual violence remain low.
  • Structural Barriers: Factors like caste and community status heighten risks for vulnerable groups, such as working-class women and lower-caste Dalits.

Flaws in the Judicial System

Justice is often delayed, with calls for quicker legal processes. This sluggishness sometimes leads to vigilante justice, which is not a solution.

Supreme Court’s Role

The Supreme Court has intervened to restore convictions under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act and the Indian Penal Code (IPC). This highlights the need for states to enforce laws effectively.

Why In News

The issue of sexual violence against women is deeply concerning, and it’s essential to explore why our legal framework sometimes falls short in addressing this pervasive problem, as understanding these shortcomings is crucial for implementing effective reforms that protect and empower survivors.

MCQs about Addressing Sexual Violence Against Women

  1. What is defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) as any sexual act or attempt to obtain a sexual act using coercion?
    A. Sexual Harassment
    B. Sexual Violence
    C. Domestic Abuse
    D. Emotional Manipulation
    Correct Answer: B. Sexual Violence
    Explanation: According to the WHO, sexual violence encompasses various forms of sexual acts or attempts that involve coercion, including rape.
  2. Which of the following issues, in addition to rape, is highlighted as a significant concern regarding violence against women in India?
    A. Workplace Discrimination
    B. Dowry Deaths
    C. Financial Inequality
    D. Political Corruption
    Correct Answer: B. Dowry Deaths
    Explanation: The essay mentions that dowry deaths are a critical issue in India, with thousands occurring annually and a low conviction rate for the accused.
  3. What significant aspect does the concept of intersectionality emphasize in understanding sexual violence legislation?
    A. Economic Status
    B. Gender Identity
    C. Multiple Social Factors
    D. Geographic Location
    Correct Answer: C. Multiple Social Factors
    Explanation: Intersectionality considers how various factors like class, caste, religion, and geography influence perceptions and outcomes related to gender violence.
  4. What recent legal development did the Supreme Court intervene in regarding the Calcutta High Court’s advice to adolescent girls?
    A. It reinforced the High Court’s ruling.
    B. It emphasized the protection of children from sexual offences.
    C. It dismissed all cases of sexual violence.
    D. It created new laws against sexual harassment.
    Correct Answer: B. It emphasized the protection of children from sexual offences.
    Explanation: The Supreme Court set aside the controversial advice from the Calcutta High Court, highlighting the importance of safeguarding children from sexual violence.

Boost up your confidence by appearing our Weekly Current Affairs Multiple Choice Questions

Loading