Hindu Editorial Analysis : 31-December-2024

The interim government of Bangladesh, led by Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus, has formally requested that India extradite Sheikh Hasina, the Prime Minister of Bangladesh. Hasina is accused of conspiracy, genocide, and crimes against humanity. This request highlights the complex issue of international extradition, where one country asks another to surrender an individual accused or convicted of serious crimes.

What is Extradition?

Extradition is a legal process where one country seeks the surrender of a person to face charges or serve a sentence in the requesting country. It ensures that criminals cannot escape justice simply by fleeing to another country. India, with a robust network of extradition treaties, plays a significant role in global law enforcement efforts.

India’s Extradition Framework

India’s extradition laws are governed by the Extradition Act of 1962, which sets out the procedures for requesting and granting extradition. The law ensures that extradition requests are handled transparently and in accordance with international standards. India has signed bilateral treaties with various countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, and Bangladesh.

Significance of Extradition Treaties

Extradition treaties serve multiple purposes:

  • Strengthening Legal Cooperation: These treaties prevent criminals from escaping justice across borders, thus promoting the rule of law.
  • Enhancing Diplomatic Ties: Extradition agreements reflect mutual trust and cooperation in fighting transnational crime. For example, treaties with countries like the US and Thailand have led to improved diplomatic relations.
  • Combating Transnational Crimes: Extradition helps tackle global crimes such as terrorism, drug trafficking, and money laundering.
Challenges in Extradition

Despite the benefits, extradition can be complicated by several factors:

  • Legal Differences: Different legal systems and standards of evidence can create challenges in processing extradition requests.
  • Human Rights Concerns: Requests can be denied if there is a risk that the individual will face inhumane treatment or an unfair trial.
  • Political Issues: Extradition treaties often exclude political offenses, which may complicate cases like Sheikh Hasina’s, where political motivations are involved.
  • Practical and Logistical Issues: Gathering sufficient evidence and dealing with judicial delays can slow down the extradition process.
Options for India

India faces multiple options in dealing with Bangladesh’s extradition request:

  • Compliance with Extradition: India could agree to extradite Hasina, showing its commitment to international law. However, this might lead to political backlash due to Hasina’s status in Bangladesh.
  • Refusal to Extradite: India could deny the request based on the political nature of the charges. The extradition treaty with Bangladesh allows refusal for political offenses, and crimes like genocide and torture are not classified as political.
  • Conditional Extradition: India could agree to extradite Hasina with conditions, such as assurances of a fair trial and humane treatment.
  • Third-Party Mediation: India might involve an international body like the United Nations to ensure an impartial review of the case, aligning with international human rights standards.
Why In News

Recently, the interim government of Bangladesh, led by Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus, formally requested India to extradite Sheikh Hasina to face charges of conspiracy, genocide, and crimes against humanity. This request comes amidst ongoing political tensions in Bangladesh, with Hasina’s government accused of suppressing opposition and committing severe human rights violations. The call for extradition has raised significant international attention, as it involves complex legal, political, and diplomatic issues that could impact relations between the two neighboring countries.

MCQs about Extradition Request for Sheikh Hasina
  1. What is the primary purpose of extradition treaties?
    A. To allow countries to freely trade with each other
    B. To prevent criminals from escaping justice by fleeing to another country
    C. To ensure that countries maintain diplomatic relations
    D. To promote cultural exchanges between countries
    Correct Answer: B. To prevent criminals from escaping justice by fleeing to another country
    Explanation: Extradition treaties are designed to ensure that criminals cannot evade justice by crossing international borders. They allow countries to request the surrender of individuals who have committed serious crimes, ensuring that perpetrators are held accountable.
  2. What is the legal basis for extradition requests in India?
    A. The Criminal Law Act of 1950
    B. The Extradition Act of 1962
    C. The Human Rights Protection Act of 1975
    D. The Foreign Relations Act of 1990
    Correct Answer: B. The Extradition Act of 1962
    Explanation: India’s extradition process is governed by the Extradition Act of 1962, which provides the legal framework for both requesting and granting extradition. This Act ensures that extradition requests are handled according to international standards and procedures.
  3. Which of the following is NOT a challenge in the extradition process?
    A. Political offenses being excluded from extradition treaties
    B. Differences in legal systems between countries
    C. Lack of international treaties on extradition
    D. Human rights concerns regarding torture or unfair trials
    Correct Answer: C. Lack of international treaties on extradition
    Explanation: The challenge in the extradition process is not the lack of international treaties, as many countries, including India, have signed numerous extradition treaties. The real challenges lie in political offenses, differences in legal systems, and concerns about human rights violations during extradition.
  4. What is one option India has regarding Bangladesh’s request to extradite Sheikh Hasina?
    A. India must automatically extradite Hasina without any conditions
    B. India can deny the request based on political offenses
    C. India can extradite Hasina immediately due to the nature of the crimes
    D. India can refuse to extradite due to legal limitations
    Correct Answer: B. India can deny the request based on political offenses
    Explanation: India has the option to deny the extradition request if the offense is considered political in nature, as specified in the extradition treaty between India and Bangladesh. Crimes like genocide, enforced disappearance, and torture, under which Sheikh Hasina is charged, are not classified as political offenses, so India could refuse extradition based on these charges.

Boost up your confidence by appearing our Weekly Current Affairs Multiple Choice Questions

Loading