Hindu Editorial Analysis : 18-December-2023

India’s Forest Rights Act (FRA) represents a crucial shift in socio-environmental legislation, aiming to rectify historical injustices perpetuated by colonial forest policies. However, the implementation of this transformative act has faced significant hurdles, including political opportunism, forester resistance, and bureaucratic apathy.

History of Forest Rights in India

Colonial Period:

  • Local communities enjoyed customary rights over forests.
  • The 1878 Indian Forest Act justified forest takeover based on ’eminent domain,’ disrupting traditional practices.

Post-Independence:

  • Forest areas of princely States were declared state property hastily.
  • Forest lands were leased but never regularized, exacerbating issues.

Wildlife Protection Act 1972 and Forest Conservation Act 1980:

  • Forced resettlement during sanctuary and national park creation.
  • Local communities’ views ignored in diverting forests for development.
Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers Act

About:

  • Enacted in 2006, FRA legally recognizes rights of traditional forest communities.
  • Aims to reduce state control, empower local self-governance, and promote conservation and developmental activities.

Legal Recognition:

  • Recognizes rights of communities living in forests since time immemorial.
  • Shifts away from excess state control, democratizing forest governance.

Local Self-Governance:

  • Empowers marginalized tribal communities.
  • Promotes democratic, bottom-up forest governance.

Conservation & Development:

  • Preserves traditional knowledge and intellectual property rights.
  • Provides guidelines for developmental facilities in forested areas.

Poverty Alleviation:

  • Focuses on pro-poor growth and poverty alleviation.
  • Addresses conflicts over supposed ‘forest encroachments.’
Significance of the Act

About:

  • Acknowledges historical injustices.
  • Recognizes individual forest rights (IFRs) and community forest rights.

IFRs:

  • Addresses ‘encroachments’ by recognizing IFRs.
  • Forest villages to be converted into revenue villages.

Community Forest Rights:

  • Recognizes village communities’ rights to access and use forests.
  • Ensures decentralization of forest governance.

Democratic Procedure:

  • Establishes a democratic procedure for wildlife conservation decisions.
  • Links community rights to authority and responsibility in forest management.
Challenges

Implementation Barriers:

  • Political opportunism, forester resistance, bureaucratic apathy.
  • Discourse clouded by misconceptions, hindering FRA’s promises.

Absurd Digital Processes:

  • Poorly implemented digital processes in connectivity-limited areas.
  • ‘Forest villages’ issue remains unaddressed in many states.

No Recognition of Community Rights:

  • Slow and incomplete recognition of community forest rights.
  • Maharashtra, Odisha, and Chhattisgarh show progress, but challenges persist.
Why In News

Political opportunism, forester resistance, and bureaucratic apathy have significantly impeded the effective implementation of the Forest Rights Act, hindering the rightful empowerment of marginalized communities in accessing their forest resources.

MCQs about Forest Rights Act in India

  1. What was the primary impact of the 1878 Indian Forest Act during the colonial period in India?
    A. Empowered local communities over forest resources
    B. Recognized customary rights of tribal communities
    C. Resulted in a disruption of traditional practices
    D. Fostered cooperation between local communities and the Imperial Forest Department
    Correct Answer: C. Resulted in a disruption of traditional practices
    Explanation: The 1878 Indian Forest Act disrupted traditional practices by justifying forest takeover based on ’eminent domain,’ impacting local communities’ customary rights.
  2. What is the main objective of the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act (FRA)?
    A. Increase state control over forests
    B. Empower local self-governance
    C. Expand wildlife sanctuaries
    D. Promote illegal encroachments in forests
    Correct Answer: B. Empower local self-governance
    Explanation: The main objective of the FRA is to empower local self-governance, reduce state control over forests, and recognize the rights of traditional forest communities.
  3. What significant provision in the Forest Rights Act ensures decentralized forest governance and links authority to community rights?
    A. Individual Forest Rights (IFRs)
    B. Community Forest Rights (CFRs)
    C. Provisions for poverty alleviation
    D. Guidelines for developmental facilities
    Correct Answer: B. Community Forest Rights (CFRs)
    Explanation: Community Forest Rights (CFRs) ensure decentralized forest governance by recognizing village communities’ rights to access, use, and manage forests within their customary boundaries.
  4. What major challenges hinder the effective implementation of the Forest Rights Act?
    A. Technological advancements
    B. Political opportunism, forester resistance, bureaucratic apathy
    C. Strong community engagement
    D. Excessive recognition of community rights
    Correct Answer: B. Political opportunism, forester resistance, bureaucratic apathy
    Explanation: Political opportunism, forester resistance, and bureaucratic apathy are highlighted as major challenges hindering the effective implementation of the Forest Rights Act.

Boost up your confidence by appearing our Weekly Current Affairs Multiple Choice Questions

Loading