Daily Current Affairs : 17-January-2024

India has recently revised its windfall tax on petroleum crude, reducing it to 1,700 rupees ($20.53) per tonne from the previous 2,300 rupees per tonne, as per a government notification. This move has sparked discussions about the nature and implications of windfall taxes in the context of the global energy market.

What is a Windfall Tax?

Windfall taxes are designed to target profits generated by companies due to external, unforeseen events, such as the energy price surge resulting from the Russia-Ukraine conflict. These taxes are imposed retrospectively and are intended to capture gains that cannot be attributed to the company’s active efforts, like strategic investments or business expansion.

  • Defined by U.S. Congressional Research Service as “unearned, unanticipated gain in income through no additional effort or expense.”
  • Levied as a one-off tax over and above regular tax rates.
  • Commonly discussed in the oil market due to volatile profits resulting from price fluctuations.
Why are Countries Implementing Windfall Taxes Now?

The global rise in oil, gas, and coal prices, fueled by pandemic recovery and supply issues from the Russia-Ukraine conflict, has prompted countries to consider windfall taxes. Energy companies witnessed record profits, leading to discussions about the fairness of such gains and the need for redistributive measures.

  • Energy price surge due to pandemic recovery and geopolitical conflicts.
  • Windfall profits benefiting energy companies while burdening consumers.
  • Multiple rationales for implementing windfall taxes, including wealth redistribution and funding social welfare programs.
Issues with Imposing Windfall Taxes:

While the intention behind windfall taxes may be to address economic imbalances, their implementation raises several concerns.

  • Uncertainty in the Market:
    • Windfall taxes imposed retrospectively create uncertainty, impacting companies’ confidence in investing.
    • Stability in the tax regime is crucial for attracting investments in a sector.
  • IMF’s Advice Note:
    • The IMF warns about design problems in windfall taxes, citing their expedient and political nature.
    • Introducing temporary windfall profit taxes may reduce future investment due to perceived tax risks.
  • CRS Report:
    • Defining true windfall profits poses a challenge, as rapid price increases may be seen as unforeseeable gains or just rewards for industry risk-taking.
    • The question of who should be taxed arises, with considerations for both major and smaller companies, and thresholds for exemptions.
Important Points:
  • What is a Windfall Tax?
    • Targets profits from external, unforeseen events.
    • Imposed retrospectively, capturing unearned gains.
    • Common in the oil market due to volatile profits.
  • Why are Countries Implementing Windfall Taxes Now?
    • Global rise in oil, gas, and coal prices.
    • Fueled by pandemic recovery and geopolitical conflicts.
    • Energy companies witness record profits.
  • Issues with Imposing Windfall Taxes:
    • Uncertainty in the Market:
      • Imposed retrospectively creates market uncertainty.
      • Affects investor confidence and sector investments.
    • IMF’s Advice Note:
      • Warns of design problems in windfall taxes.
      • Temporary windfall taxes may reduce future investments.
    • CRS Report:
      • Challenges in defining true windfall profits.
      • Debate on who should be taxed, major or smaller companies.
      • Considerations for thresholds and exemptions.
Why In News

India cut its windfall tax on petroleum crude to 1,700 rupees ($20.53) a tonne from 2,300 rupees a tonne, signaling a move to boost the energy sector and alleviate financial burdens on both consumers and businesses, according to a recent government notification.

MCQs about Windfall Tax

  1. What is the primary objective of windfall taxes?
    A. To encourage strategic investments
    B. To capture profits from unforeseen external events
    C. To stabilize market prices
    D. To promote business expansion
    Correct Answer: B. To capture profits from unforeseen external events
    Explanation: Windfall taxes aim to target profits generated by companies due to external, unforeseen events, capturing gains that cannot be attributed to the company’s active efforts.
  2. Why have countries considered implementing windfall taxes recently?
    A. Economic recession
    B. Decline in energy prices
    C. Global rise in oil, gas, and coal prices
    D. Reduction in energy demand
    Correct Answer: C. Global rise in oil, gas, and coal prices
    Explanation: The recent consideration of windfall taxes is due to the global rise in oil, gas, and coal prices driven by pandemic recovery and geopolitical conflicts.
  3. What is a key issue associated with imposing windfall taxes?
    A. Increased investor confidence
    B. Market certainty
    C. Uncertainty in the market about future taxes
    D. Stable tax regime
    Correct Answer: C. Uncertainty in the market about future taxes
    Explanation: Windfall taxes imposed retrospectively can create uncertainty in the market about future taxes, impacting investor confidence.
  4. According to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), what potential issue may arise with temporary windfall profit taxes?
    A. Enhanced future investments
    B. Reduced future investments
    C. Market stability
    D. Expedited tax collection
    Correct Answer: B. Reduced future investments
    Explanation: The IMF warns that introducing temporary windfall profit taxes may reduce future investment due to perceived tax risks.

Boost up your confidence by appearing our Weekly Current Affairs Multiple Choice Questions

Loading